I chose the Petal sandal and it was love at first sight. I've been looking for a light tan casual sandal for warm weather and I think these fit the bill to a T. The leather and rope detailing are nice. The wedge heels gives me a 3" lift (much needed for a shortie like me) without feeling like it, and the cushioned insoles and traction outsoles are super-comfy. I also found the Petal to be lighter than previous years' sandal models.
As for fit, I think the Petal runs pretty true-to-size to a tad small. I ended up ordering 1/2 a size up from my usual based on my other Jambus, but I think my normal would have worked as well (what can I say, I've got long toesies). My feet do border on being a wide width though, so I think if you ladies are narrow-footed, these may be a bit too wide for you.
What I don't like about the Petal? The parts of the insoles that are covered with a silky-satin material. While it isn't slick or too shiny (and honestly not really noticeable when you've got your foot covering it), I wonder if the material will get dirty easily or wear down quickly.
Wearing these totally made me feel a bit boho chic, so I had to pair the sandals with my Lunar Cycles wannabe top and some worn-in jeans. I wore this look over the weekend and must admit my feet were comfy-comfy through the entire day.
Top: F21 lace flutter (sim but pricey, more cas, looser, dress)
Jeans: J.Crew destroyed matchstick (worn here - sim, sim)
Necklace: Overstock (sim, sim)
Earrings: T+J Designs stone dangle (worn here - sim, longer, lighter, silver)
Bracelets: F21 stud, Old Navy enamel, Goody double wear (sim, sim, sim)
Shoes: c/o Jambu petal (get them here, here, here)